Legal Grounds for an auto accident case in Maine.


Article provided by Hallett, Zerillo & Whipple Law 
Visit us at

If you have been injured in an automobile accident in Maine, you may wonder whether you can bring a lawsuit for your injuries and other damages. As a former insurance adjuster and current Plaintiff's lawyer, I have seen both sides of the sometimes complex area of automobile accident negligence. I hope to provide you a framework for an understanding of this legal topic here.

Most automobile injury claims are based on the tort of negligence. A "tort" is a "wrong" committed by someone against another. A "tortfeasor" is the "wrongdoer" of the tort.

In order to prove the tort of negligence, the Plaintiff must prove by a preponderance of the evidence: first, that the Defendant was negligent, second, that the Defendant's negligence was a proximate cause (or legal cause) of the Plaintiff's injury and consequent damages, and third, that the Plaintiff suffered damages as a result of the accident.

The first step is to determine if there was a negligent act. Negligence is doing something that an ordinary, careful person would not do, or failure to do something that an ordinary, careful person would do in the same situation. It is, in other words, a failure to use ordinary care under the circumstances considering all the evidence in the case.

If you have a case where the person who struck you was negligent, the second step is to determine if their negligence was the cause of your injuries. Proximate (or legal) cause is "that cause which, in natural or continuous sequence, unbroken by an efficient intervening cause, produces the injury, and without which the result would not have occurred." Curtis v. Jacobson, 142 Me. 351, 54 A.2d 520.

So, a negligent act is proximately caused if (1) the actor's conduct is a substantial factor in bringing about the harm, and (2) he is not legally relieved from liability by another law. This is the so-called "substantial factor" test. [1] The negligent act must also be either the direct result or reasonably foreseeable consequence of the negligence. Merriam v. Wanger, 757 A.2d 778 (Me. 2000). So, to have proximate cause, you need to prove the following:

  1. The negligent act was a substantial factor in bringing about the harm;
  2. The law does not otherwise relieve the tortfeasor of liability; and
  3. The negligent act was either the direct result or a reasonably foreseeable consequence of the negligence

If you have proven negligence and causation, the third step is to recover for your damages. You can recover for your injuries, pain and suffering, emotional distress, lost wages and lost future earnings if your negligence claim succeeds.

This assumes, of course, that the negligent actor has either the insurance or the resources to pay for the damages you have suffered. In most automobile accident cases, there is at least some insurance available for you to recover money for your injuries. Likewise, your own uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage may cover any deficiency in the tortfeasor's insurance.

We Are Your Legal Team

When you have a Serious Injury, Criminal Defense, or Family Law matter anywhere in Maine.